Originally Posted by
kevo The base timing is the starting point, it should be set according to your timming map and if not this will affect both mid and high end, if base is so high you could get some knocks causing your ECU to pull the timing up top.
First, the OP has a tuned ecu and he never showed his timing map. So how can anybody( without seeing the map) jump to the conclusion the timing is too high?
When a car gets tuned on a dyno, it usually run at full throttle from 3,000rpm to what ever rpm the peak power occurs. The timing and afr is adjusted for the those rpm range. With a tuneable ecu, you can change the idle timing without affecting the other part of the rpm and vice versa.
As an example, let say one engine has very radical cams and has problem idling. I can help it out by adding timing to idle rpm and leave the rest of the timing map alone. I’ve added 20 degrees to some engines to help them idle. But base on your reasoning, the 20 degree at idle is too high for peak power, which is flawed. In this case, one has nothing to do with the other.
When I tune a car for peak power, I want know the total or peak timing for peak power. I could care less what timing you have at idle.
The more relevant question to the OP is: what is the peak timing?