Nobody ever listens to me anyway,but here goes .
This is from my personal exprience,not what I "heard" or "read somewhere".
Yes, JWT ECU are said to be a little rich for obvious reasons.But they don't sell them so rich that you smell gas.That rediculous...no way they have sold so many ECUs for 500 bucks each all these years if that was the case.
-First thing you should do is get the numbers from inside the ECU and call JWT and see if you have the tune you think you have.
-If it is indeed a POP program tuned for S3 cams,you should not be so rich that you smell fumes.I think you have a different problem if thats the case.
The reason I say this is because I have run a JWT ECU with the same tune on a DE with stock cams, CAI,header and catback.Before It was installed,I called and talked to a tech at JWT to see what their opinion was on running this ECU on the car until the cams are installed(if ever,lol) .I was told that it will not be too rich and the difference from a standard POP NA program for stock cams and the program for cams is more timing adjustments than fuel adjustments. dont have a wideband,but I have driven 4 tanks of gas so far,and there is definately a difference from stock.No difference in gas mileage,in fact I gained about 1 mpg since the install.NO fumes,NO black smoke or black stains on the back of the car.
-Check fuel tank vent lines,and/or the oring around the fuelpump under the back seat.They will cause the fume smell just as easily.
Oh...if you do give up on this...hope you dont
....then I will take those S3 cams off our hands