Welcome to the SR20 Community Forum - The Dash.
Register
SR20 forum logo

Thread: Timing Maps for Tuning

+ Reply To Thread
Posts: 31-40 of 156
2011-02-10 16:13:25
#31
Originally Posted by Vadim
It will be a direct translation to the ECU right? No need to go through a bunch of calculations?



Right, it would be direct translation to and from the ECU.

No need to do a bunch of calculations, that is what the computer is for.
2011-02-10 18:00:01
#32
Excellent! Thank you guys (Dave and John) a lot!
2011-02-11 02:31:50
#33
Originally Posted by BenFenner
supercowboy, are you comparing the stock DET ignition map at 65 TP? Because 65 TP on the stock map may not correlate to 5 psi depending on the MAF used, and the K-value used. Frankly, trying to compare these TP maps with one another is just about useless unless you know you're using the same TP scale, K-value, and MAF.


Your right, But when you look at this map even where the tp scale says he is in boost the timing numbers are high. Im just going on what is stated. Another thing you have to look at is the car might be falling back to the knock map if timing is to high. for all we know the car might be seeing stock values in the knock map and the car will drive fine. no matter how you set the map up your full throttle should be in the last 2 columns. When I see a factory map the last 2 columns are in low teens or even single digits. Im sure nissan spent a crap load of money to figure this out. Why not start out withe a nissan base value and move up.

Originally Posted by BenFenner
I'm starting to wonder how useful it is to even post them on the forum.

However running 28 degrees of timing at 135 kPa (5 psi) seems well within the realm of the norm for a 8.5:1 SR20DET engine with restrictive stock cams/valves.
And the other map that has 22 degrees at 170 kPa (10 psi) is right there too in my opinion.
Maybe you're not used to dealing with such low pressures on such crappy flowing engines?


In a Gtir stock timing map the car will see 15 degrees of timing at 3000 rpm at 60 tp. So what your telling me is advancing this 13 degrees is ok and a good place to start. In my experience as boost goes up timing goes down. even enthalpy timing theory starts the cars at 19 psi which I still think its much, But again he is going by a typical rule of thumb. take .75 degree per psi of boost.

Originally Posted by BenFenner
I need to post up my current ignition map once I'm confident with it. You might like it better. It has 13 degrees at 170 kPa (10 psi) right now.
But I have a 9.5:1 SR20DE+T with the low port head/intake and a '91 cam so maybe that's closer to what you're used to seeing?


I would like to take a look at that

Originally Posted by BenFenner
I can only confirm the "unattributed GT3076R DET Tune" AEM ignition map was checked with a timing light for accuracy at idle and there's no reason to believe it would be off anywhere else since anything to pull timing was disabled and it's not like AEM is known for significant ignition timing jitters or wavering at high load or rpm.


Did you check it at 6000 Rpms Ive seen cars showing different timing numbers there do to bad distributors and hall effects.
2011-02-11 02:50:35
#34
Originally Posted by BenFenner
I see what he's saying. Calum has 15-17 degrees at torque peak (5,200 - 5,600 rpm) and 69 TP whereas you have 28 degrees at torgue peak and 65 TP. That's a huge difference. But the problem is, 65 TP on one of these maps has almost no relation to 65 (or 69) TP on another map because of how the different MAFs and K-values fuck with TP.

That's no excuse. The area should be tuned properly even if you don't spend more than split seconds there on your way through it. It's not even hard to do. Well, maybe on the TP maps it is. (Is it hard to tell I despise TP?)


K value is a base to where you need to be. Putting a mass air meter causes the tp to go up or down whichever size you go with.

TP is your load scale on the map. The only way you know what psi is your tp is by a boost pressure sensor. The nissan ecu does not know it has boost it just measure airflow across the maf sensor Then calculates with throttle position and rpm. Then it puts it where it needs to be in the map. Pretty simple.
2011-02-11 02:56:22
#35
Originally Posted by Vadim
Yup I know it's no excuse, but I've had no audible knock to worry about it. But with new flow mods I will definitely look into using the lighter version of Ethalapy's timing.


Doesnt mean the car is not detonating. Timing maps should be dialed in on a dyno makes it much easier to see changing values.



Originally Posted by Vadim
Once TunerCode supports a MAP yup, but Dave said it's up to the tuner to decide what the voltages translate to still. So what I'm getting is, even with a MAP we might not be so fine and dandy as we hope.

Dont need it. There is plenty of tuning with what you have. Most factory turbo cars run maf sensors. There must be a reason.
2011-02-11 02:59:32
#36
Originally Posted by Vadim
It will be a direct translation to the ECU right? No need to go through a bunch of calculations?

I would be fine with using MAF's and if we could get a direct translation of 4.5v = 10 psi of boost for say a z32 MAF. But I understand that need for calculation values too.

If you map trace you should see when your car hits 10 psi where it sits on the map.
2011-02-11 03:07:20
#37
AEM EMS Base SR20DET Tune


Motor: SR20DET (8.5:1 CR)
Mods: Completely stock from air box to tail pipe. This means T25 turbo, stock cams, top mount intercooler, etc.
Octane: 91+ (R+M)/2 gasoline
Dyno WHP: Not sure.
Safe or Tuned Map: This map is un-tuned and designed to be safe to use as a base.



Notes: All I did was open up the base tune (calibration) provided by AEM for the common SR20DET engine, took a screen shot of the ignition table and posted it up. I didn't modify it in any way, and I don't make any claims to this map.
Last edited by BenFenner on 2015-06-26 at 16-42-20.
2011-02-11 03:09:55
#38
Originally Posted by supercowboy
Did you check it at 6000 Rpms Ive seen cars showing different timing numbers there do to bad distributors and hall effects.
Admittedly no, we did not. There was no reason to question the health or operation of the CAS and ignition system.



Take a look at the base AEM SR20DET tune I posted above. Torque peak (5,500 rpm) at 170 kPa (10 psi) is 20 degrees and that includes wiggle room as it's meant as a safe map to use as a base for tuning. Bone stock DET setups that don't breath, so they don't get any air, so you wouldn't be dealing with aggressively retarded timing like you would with an engine that breathes.

Originally Posted by supercowboy
I would like to take a look at that
I'll post up my timing map in a bit when I'm more confident in it. For now though I'll send it to you in a PM if you want. Not trying to hide it, just don't think it belongs in this thread yet. It might undergo some minor changes this spring. Maybe I'll post it up in my build thread for now...
Last edited by BenFenner on 2011-02-11 at 03-27-32.
2011-02-11 03:42:10
#39
Supercowboy, take a look at Enthalpy base map, mine is pretty much identical to it, except I smoothed it out and built on it a little bit. Now Enthalpy does mention that being a base map to build on. This could be based on RWD SR20DET. But I can't imagine RWD DET being too different from FWD DET.

Originally Posted by supercowboy
Doesnt mean the car is not detonating. Timing maps should be dialed in on a dyno makes it much easier to see changing values.


Dont need it. There is plenty of tuning with what you have. Most factory turbo cars run maf sensors. There must be a reason.


That was a 100% street tuned, I was planning to hit the dyno on it, but ended up selling the car before that happened.

Having a MAF is nice, but MAP has the easier to tune advantage. The problem I have with MAF's is finding a good turbulent free location and finding a used MAF that still has a good idle voltage.

Originally Posted by supercowboy
If you map trace you should see when your car hits 10 psi where it sits on the map.


That's what I did, it's hard to get it right and accurate though. Especially while your driving
2011-02-11 04:21:16
#40
Man those timing figures are really high. You must has access to some high octane fuels.
+ Reply To Thread
  • [Type to search users.]
  • Quick Reply
    Thread Information
    There are currently ? users browsing this thread. (? members & ? guests)
    StubUserName

    Back to top