Ok well this project is finished and I am more than satisfied with how it came out.
Home Depot didn't have the color Plasti Dip I wanted to I bought heat shrink instead..
You will need heatshrink, a heatgun and cloth gloves because the heatshrink gets hot. Make sure to let it cool for atleast 10 minutes before you touch it.
I cut off about 3/4" heat shrink and placed it sideways over the white plastic cap on the door spring and shrunk it.
Then cut out the hole using an Exacto knife or blade..whatever you have laying around
Use the remaining piece of heatshrink that you cut before and place it like this, leaving a bit of extra on both sides