I
never understood the complaint of a shifter being too "notchy"? Am I not understanding that description properly? All the best shifting transmissions, universally praised by any driver worth listening to, seems to have one thing in common from what I've experienced; they are "notchy" as fuck. You know, like a fucking bolt-action rifle. Unbelievably "notchy". No?
When I hear the word "notchy" it makes me think the shifter has very specific paths it wants to follow, and very specific places it wants to move to engage a gear. And it forces you to follow those paths. It is the opposite of a "wobbly" shifter, or one where you can pretty much shove it anywhere and it will give you
a gear.
Can someone explain this to me? WTF is a "notchy" shifter?
Also, shifter being too light? Not something you'd ever hear me complain about. How could it be too light? Weighted shift knobs are also WTF in my eyes... You want it to be weighted? Why???
A shift is three distinct motions in my book.
1) Disengage previous gear dog teeth and syncrho and enter neutral.
2) Find next desired gear's synchro location and wait a beat.
3) Move the lever home, engaging the dog teeth of the intended gear.
People with weighted shift knobs (and levers?!) all seem to me like people who treat a gear change as a single event. And maybe only care about that 1-2 shift?