Originally Posted by
nismosr20 I dont know what to do and would like some of your opinions. More so if anyone have one of these cars please chime in.I have never owned either, and actually haven't driven the e46 M3 yet, but I'll let you know my experience.
I've driven an ASP1 S2000 and I wasn't impressed.
The bad:
It felt heavy, partially because it makes no power early on, partially because it's 250 lbs. up on my daily driver, and partially because it's not a tin can.
The digital bar tach annoyed the shіt out of me.
Clutch pedal take-up provides minimal feel.
Shifter felt like a cable actuated RSX shifter (best of the cable actuated shifters, but still "fake" feeling). And this from a rod actuated shifter? Wtf.
The Good:
Seating position and visibility around "A" pillar with top down is great, much better than a Miata (on par with the 3rd gen MR2).
Now for BMW, I've driven many of them. I've driven early 3 series, 5 series, Z3s, current 335i, etc. and I've always been pleasantly surprised. They have truly earned their "ultimate driving machine" reputation. I know what I like, and it would be a BMW over most other cars. If you need a drop-top, get an M3 convertible or the M version of the Z3 or whatever, just make sure it's a BMW and you'll be fine. =D
Originally Posted by
nismosr20 relibility isnt an issue [with the S2000]
So it's ultra reliable? Sweet. I'm sure it is.
Originally Posted by
nismosr20 But all you find is abused ones
But you just said it was reliable. Who cares if it's been abused? As far as I'm concerned I prefer abused cars. I abuse my car on a daily basis.
Originally Posted by
nismosr20 But repair costs [for the BMW] are killerYou don't fix your own cars? Okay, it could get pricey.
Originally Posted by
nismosr20 and upgrading [the BMW] wouldnt be cheap either.You think go-fast parts for S2k's are cheap or cheaper than BMW parts? Think again man.