Welcome to the SR20 Community Forum - The Dash.
Register
SR20 forum logo

Thread: Think I went with too big of a turbo...

+ Reply To Thread
Posts: 191-200 of 710
2011-08-18 15:10:57
#191
Originally Posted by Boostlee
Can I tag along??

Post convention caravan!

Originally Posted by SR20GTi-R
You want to have the benefits of the higher lift while using the gears to dial out some of the overlap.

Besides, SR16 cams are cheaper and easier to source than the VET's.

I look at it this way, its cheaper to pay $300-400 on a dyno session and ensure the car is 100% than risk blowing it on the street by trial and error.

I know its not my car/motor but I just hate seeing 90% of this forum over thinking and not sticking to the essentials/basics.


How much overlap do you think it's possible to dial back on the SR16's or even SR20VE's?

There are a lot of variables with dyno tuning too. Last time I went to dyno and tune I had to redo my tune on the street because elevation differences and dyno tuning was done a colder day.

The way this motor stands right now, with 210 psi compression, it will need new pistons anyway (DET pistons and rods). That's something I already am expecting and planning for I guess .

But timing aside, looking at Coheed's dynos I'm seeing the exact same issues. Maybe it's just the Protech logs, if it is then I'm SOL either way and will have to redo the manifold/downpipe/ic piping. Perhaps your luck with log manifolds comes from using much bigger turbos? Mine is still a baby compared to what I've seen on here....
Last edited by Vadim on 2011-08-18 at 15-16-34.
2011-08-18 15:35:27
#192
Originally Posted by Vadim
SR20GTi-R mentioned the same in my WTB thread. The thing is their overlap is fairly major and I don't want to deal with the additional pains, including cam gears.

Spending big on 300whp sucks, that's all. DET would have been there already .

jpsr20det? I can send him a PM and see if he still has them .


Yeah man go for it! If he does we'll work something out cheap!
2011-08-18 15:50:51
#193



That manifold sucks willy! I would rather an ebay job. yeah sure it may crack earlier, but I would rather a braced ebay item. far less compromise.

How much are those pos's worth anyway!

p.s. Nothing against protec here, I am sure thats just their budget turbo manifold for guys converting. But that design is very compromised.

ps, coheed it looks like nearly 50hp at the same psi vet's to 16ve's. Seems like a lot to me at only 13-14psi
2011-08-18 15:52:27
#194
Originally Posted by Vadim
Post convention caravan!


It will be the lamers convention.
2011-08-18 15:58:58
#195
C
Originally Posted by SR20GTi-R
Here is what you need to do:

1 - Get a set of SR16 or 20v cams.
2- Lock and set your base timing the correct way.
3- Schedule some dyno time and see what the car is really doing.

Like I said in the other thread, tuning a timing table on the street is risky business. Without seeing what the car is doing for power/TQ everything you are doing is pointless.

Throw all the theory and other b.s out the window and get on the dyno.

The cams alone are not going to magically give you the power/spool you are looking for. Tuning is.


QFTMFT.


Communism worked in theory too.
2011-08-18 16:06:44
#196
Originally Posted by P10FTW
Communism worked in theory too.


I see what you did there :golfclap:
2011-08-18 17:41:01
#197
Originally Posted by ca18
Yeah man go for it! If he does we'll work something out cheap!


Sent you both a PM

Originally Posted by ca18
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm158/CoheedJV/Manifold/DSCN1867.jpg


That manifold sucks willy! I would rather an ebay job. yeah sure it may crack earlier, but I would rather a braced ebay item. far less compromise.

How much are those pos's worth anyway!

p.s. Nothing against protec here, I am sure thats just their budget turbo manifold for guys converting. But that design is very compromised.

ps, coheed it looks like nearly 50hp at the same psi vet's to 16ve's. Seems like a lot to me at only 13-14psi


That's your typical log manifold though. Those are not cheap either, think the one I have was $300-400 new.

Now he went with a different size AR and twin scroll when he switched to 16VE's. Just something to consider.
2011-08-18 18:28:00
#198
you can not dial out overlap on the VE cams effectively without causing other issues. By taking out too much overlap on high cams, you produce a negative overlap on the low cams. This causes it to run like crap while it is on the low cams, and ruins the cam center so it doesn't work well at all.

This is not a tuning issue. Anyone who has actually tested it would know this. But who here has done the testing? Anyone else have documentation of their results?
2011-08-18 18:34:52
#199
Originally Posted by Vadim
Another thing I'll try out is running just one high lobe cam.

If I use the intake cam only, it's 28* of overlap, if I use the exhaust cam only it's 20* of overlap. Looks like Coheed only dynoed the intake cam on without exhaust cam. Not Exhaust without intake, so it's worth a shot. As a temporary solution.


when i datalogged the ex only cam switch, the maf voltage dropped noticeably so i didn't bother to dyno just the exhaust cam. By dyno results were based on JWT's suggestions back when i did that testing.

I battled for a long time to try to get power levels where i felt they should be. Now, power levels are very respectable on low boost, and still a little shy on the high boost power levels.
2011-08-18 18:35:06
#200
Im going with Coheed again. Nobody has put more time, money and dyno time into these setups than he has.

I highly doubt its a tuning issue. I know Vadim knows what he is doing when he is tuning his car. No reason he cant street tune his car at that power level. I did it to my last 2 setups and they were way more power. A 250-300whp car is much easier to handle and tune on the streets vs a 460-650whp car is when all you do is spin. But as far as my tune after fixing the ignition, it was perfectly fine, great a/f, smooth, no more knocking and made insane power all street tuned.

Nothing wrong with him street tuning his 300whp car. You can listen for knock, log knock and so on. All you need.

Like Coheed said you can only dial out soo much overlap before the car just runs like crap on the low lobes. You can probably get rid of about 10 deg and still have the idle manageable and run "ok" on the low lobes. VET cams are his only option for this setup if he wants to make more power and have more reliability and safer standings with the motor.

Again when you can show testing done then maybe we will talk.
+ Reply To Thread
  • [Type to search users.]
  • Quick Reply
    Thread Information
    There are currently ? users browsing this thread. (? members & ? guests)
    StubUserName

    Back to top