Thread: Another P11 bites the dust..

+ Reply To Thread

First

Last

Posts: 11-20 of 30

Search Thread

2010-03-08 13:31:28

#11

Andreas Miko Online/offline status of Andreas Miko is unknown

Jah Guide

Join Date: 2007-12-11
Location: Miami, FL
Posts: 8,326
Trader Score: 122 (100%)

Originally Posted by SR20GTi-R

Well the first P11 was a 2001, which took 3 years of hard abuse. Track, dyno etc.

The second was a 99 so I expected it to go, just not after a few pulls. I guess its time to swap stacks in the 01' and throw it back in.

You cant count the 99 P11 tranny as a P11 tranny, thats an old school tranny.

The newer 00-02 trannys dont go out like that,

0 Likes

Be the first to like this post.

Good Thoughts Bring Good Vibes Which Bring Good Reasoning

I Am A JWT Dealer And VRS Dealer.

If you need any help 305-282-3643

I sell SR20VE, SR20DE and SR20DET motors

Reply Reply With Quote

2010-03-08 13:43:19

#12

Cliff

Member

Join Date: 2007-12-11
Location: Bel Air, MD.
Posts: 11,653
Trader Score: 20 (100%)

Originally Posted by Andreas
You cant count the 99 P11 tranny as a P11 tranny, thats an old school tranny.

The newer 00-02 trannys dont go out like that,

But they do blow. He blew out 4th on the 01 P11 as described. Sure it took a lot longer, but it still went bye bye.

0 Likes

Be the first to like this post.

'17 Golf R

Reply Reply With Quote

2010-03-08 13:46:12

#13

erick212

focused

Join Date: 2007-12-11
Location:
Posts: 311
Trader Score: 0 (0%)

Oh no not again...... LOL@ bgreen for the inviso brakes

0 Likes

Be the first to like this post.

06 Frontier - tow truck
low post count=working on cars more than computers
SR20deep Ct.
Sr20deeper for all the cool kids
Question: What if I don’t have a magazine with ammunition in it?
Answer: How are your negotiating skills? LOL
Lock and load people, it's a different world out there

[url]www.thelionsdenct.com[/url]

Reply Reply With Quote

2010-03-08 13:48:59

#14

Andreas Miko Online/offline status of Andreas Miko is unknown

Jah Guide

Join Date: 2007-12-11
Location: Miami, FL
Posts: 8,326
Trader Score: 122 (100%)

Originally Posted by Cliff

But they do blow. He blew out 4th on the 01 P11 as described. Sure it took a lot longer, but it still went bye bye.

You are arguing a point that is silly. No one has ever said the newer P11 tranny will not brake. All that has been said it will last way longer. 3 years of a motor making 400-500 WHP or hard abuse should say something.

No trans that is designed to take 150 HP will stand up to 3 times or 4 times the power for ever. Nothing is forever. Everything will eventually die or break, its inevitable.

You put an old school tranny in a 500 WHP car you are just throwing away money. The best thing is the P11, even the 6 spd trannies brake.

0 Likes

Be the first to like this post.

Good Thoughts Bring Good Vibes Which Bring Good Reasoning

I Am A JWT Dealer And VRS Dealer.

If you need any help 305-282-3643

I sell SR20VE, SR20DE and SR20DET motors

Reply Reply With Quote

2010-03-08 13:59:16

#15

Cliff

Member

Join Date: 2007-12-11
Location: Bel Air, MD.
Posts: 11,653
Trader Score: 20 (100%)

Originally Posted by Andreas
You are arguing a point that is silly. No one has ever said the newer P11 tranny will not brake. All that has been said it will last way longer. 3 years of a motor making 400-500 WHP or hard abuse should say something.

No trans that is designed to take 150 HP will stand up to 3 times or 4 times the power for ever. Nothing is forever. Everything will eventually die or break, its inevitable.

You put an old school tranny in a 500 WHP car you are just throwing away money. The best thing is the P11, even the 6 spd trannies brake.

Dre,

All I'm saying is what I highlighted in your post. We both said it, just in different ways. I'm not arguing the fact that it's somehow not believable that the 99 P11 broke. Everyone knows that the stack is the same as the horrid B13/B14 stack.

0 Likes

Be the first to like this post.

'17 Golf R

Reply Reply With Quote

2010-03-09 02:03:37

#16

Coheed

My Vtec Gives Hugs mmmbah

Join Date: 2007-12-13
Location:
Posts: 4,537
Trader Score: 3 (100%)

hehehehehehe.

Yes the P11 (the REAL one) will last longer. But I broke one, and I am easy on the clutch when shifting. Mine blew at the top of 2nd gear, just before shifting to 3rd. I thought the exhaust was dragging on the ground too lol.

Yes they break, but mine took over 20K miles of well over 100 drag passes on street tires. Here's hoping the new one holds up even better since it has WAY less miles on it to begin with.

0 Likes

Be the first to like this post.

BRZ Limited Dark Gray Metalllic. Oh yea.

Reply Reply With Quote

2010-03-09 02:14:39

#17

morgans432 Online/offline status of morgans432 is unknown

Member

Join Date: 2008-11-04
Location: Central NJ
Posts: 8,300
Trader Score: 51 (100%)

Car sounds good as always and get that crap fixed for this weekend.

0 Likes

Be the first to like this post.

living the dream

Reply Reply With Quote

2010-03-09 02:37:29

#18

ashtonsser Online/offline status of ashtonsser is unknown

SR20VETeran

Join Date: 2007-12-11
Location: Copperas Cove, Tx
Posts: 9,349
Trader Score: 13 (100%)

exactly why im going 6 speed. I was talking to mazworx today and just the side by side comparison from an older 5 speed and yes even the 00+ P11 trans is a night and day difference. He was saying the gears look at least 10X as beefier than even the P11 trans. No only are the gears wider the teeth are thicker and made of better materials. He was saying they should hold up for a long time in a very high hp SR.

My stuff is on order as we speak. No more Sr trannies for me. Ill also be running an 85w 140 gear oil in it as well for extra cusion. Cant wait.

0 Likes

Be the first to like this post.

1992 Nissan Sentra SE-R - Fully Built SR20VE, BWS400SX Billet 67mm and much more
JMS Racing tuned to 716whp, 423wtq at 29psi
10.5 @ 149.2mph to date I believe the fastest trap speed SE-R, Much more to come with some changes!

Reply Reply With Quote

2010-03-09 20:15:09

#19

SR20GTi-R

Member

Join Date: 2007-12-14
Location:
Posts: 1,913
Trader Score: 5 (100%)

Put in my B15 trans for now..

Went out for some runs last night against some Honda boys.

Wish I could post vids :-(

0 Likes

Be the first to like this post.

Tired..of the bullshit.

Reply Reply With Quote

2010-03-09 20:21:26