I know what im talking about like ive dealt with turbo cars since I was like 12 granted im only 18 I build them and work on them everyday. This one just stumps me.
I found out I have the stock actuator on and i mean like bone stock never been changed and i think the spring in it is only rated for a weak 8-9 psi I found this on another forum:
The reason why you would buy the HKS actuator is to hold boost better. On the stock T25, boost will fall off as much as 3-4 psi, and the HKS actuator makes it so that you only lose about 0.5-1psi instead of several lbs of boost.
The boost controller is useless past 5,000rpm with the stock actuator, because if you have it set at like 12psi, then after 5k rpm, you'll drop down as low as 8-9psi. Seen this with my own eyes and i have a redtop w/stock t25.
The problem with the stock actuators is that the springs are not as strong, expecially since it is older. SInce the spring is weaker, it actually starts to open, regardless of the boost controller that you are running. The boost controller does not hold the wastegate shut, it keeps the boost signal from reaching the actuator which would normally open it. The boost controller is basically a bleeder, but a very precise one.
If you got the HKS unit, you would be able to hold the boost longer, with or without a boost controller.
Like Alex said, the stocker bleeds off boost at higher pressure due to the back pressure pushing on the actuator puck and the spring not being able to hold the puck against the housing.
If you only add the HKS actuator, your top end will imporve from the turbo holding the boost longer on the top end. We have done this to MANY SRs. You can see it happen on the dyno when you are logging the boost.