Originally Posted by
kieron there are obviously an awful lot of people "doing it wrong" in the eyes of Ben FennerThere certainly is.
You're also wrong about the professional/amateur tuners. Tuning to 12.0:1 on high boost applications is common enough. I understand most shops will not send a car out like that because their reputation is on the line, and they've heard rumors/can't trust the kid with the car to not fuсk it up down the road. They know they will take the heat for that. You can be damn sure they tune their own cars to 12.0:1 and the amateurs follow suit with great results.
All of the advice I've gotten from tuners I trust have recommended what I said for modern DOHC boost friendly engines.
Hell, even older SOHC engines with poor anti-detonation head designs should be tuned to 12.0:1. I've done it, and I hold the US record on pump gas for that engine partially due to that. Engine was daily driven on 21 psi, GT35 turbo, etc. etc.
It's called over fueling, and it's a band aid at best.
Originally Posted by
kieron i personally do not know a single person that tunes for 12's up top on a turbo application when running anything more than a farts worth of psi through a turbo. Whether they are self tuners or well respected professsionals. Not one.You know me. Or do the interwebs not count?
I'm not trying to belittle you kieron, but it seems to me like you're stuck in the world of controlling detonation with fuel. Sure, it can be done, to an extent, and it's certainly cheap and easy, but detonation is much better controlled with ignition timing (as I'm sure you know). Maybe you've been hanging around the SAFC crowd too much?