Welcome to the SR20 Community Forum - The Dash.
Register
SR20 forum logo

Thread: What kind of Intercooler

+ Reply To Thread
Posts: 11-20 of 120
2008-10-23 19:23:32
#11
Originally Posted by BenFenner
Andreas, yours is a 20" core where mine is 24". You know what that means.


If the core length on your si 24 then the total with tanks will be 32 in or so. These intercoolers have fittment issues with piping. Again my opinion.

I like the cores in the 18-20in range.
2008-10-23 19:25:20
#12
Just to claryfied something Bigger FMIC does not mean more lag , a well made fmic will have LESS lag and a better reduce in temp.
If you want a nice made ebay fmic get the AMS copy for the evo8
2008-10-23 19:26:16
#13
Originally Posted by Andreas
Stay away from the ones with the 24 in cores that come out to a total length of 32 in with endtanks on
That's the one I meant to post, god damn it. Why stay away? Just curious. I'll probably find out sooner or later, as that's what I have waiting to go in. =]

Edit: Nm you answered me above. We'll just have to see how much cutting I have to do. I agree maybe smaller with no cutting would be a better choice. Depends what you're willing to go through for that extra inch³. =]
2008-10-23 19:26:33
#14
Originally Posted by jpsr20det
Just to claryfied something Bigger FMIC does not mean more lag , a well made fmic will have LESS lag and a better reduce in temp.
If you want a nice made ebay fmic get the AMS copy for the evo8


Those are good to as they have the piping facing down and you can run a better piping setup.
2008-10-23 19:31:26
#15
Originally Posted by Andreas
Use the one I listed, in my opinion you will be able to have more space to run piping properly. 12 in tall is not a problem. I woud go with a taller intercooler 12 v 9 because you would have less pressure drop across the core, there will be more runners for the air to travel acroess easier. Less work by motor means more HP to the wheels. Again it is my opinion.


^Thanks.
2008-10-24 00:25:07
#16
Originally Posted by BenFenner


As for Johnny wangwang's comments about lag. I'm glad he brought it up, because it gives me another opportunity to educate, and debunk this horrible myth. Johnny, can you quickly explain why you would experience slower boost onset ("turbo lag" isn't really correct here) with a larger intercooler?


LOL why even ask the question if its such a horrible myth?? Just "Debunk" the bitch then. Anyway the more area you have to fill the more time its going to take to fill that area with air to the point that its pressurized. Also tube and fin has benifits also since it will let the front of the car breathe alot better then a bar and plate. This is the reason why I run a Johnny Race car Tube and fin on my NX instead of the ebay bar and plates.


and...slower boost onset....turbo lag....same **** cause its gonna feel just like turbo lag till it builds pressure.
2008-10-24 01:55:44
#17
I am running the johnny race car setup. It is the 5" tall rig. What type of hp should it support? I looked at most of the ebay specials that were posted. With those 9 and 12 inch units, the bumper support will have to be hacked up, correct?
2008-10-24 02:02:35
#18
You do not have to mess with the bumper suport.
2008-10-24 02:04:53
#19
Originally Posted by Andreas
You do not have to mess with the bumper suport.


are you mounting it in front of the support then? if i mount it underneath like i have it now, it will be hanging down past the bumper.
2008-10-24 02:05:57
#20
Originally Posted by Johnny
LOL why even ask the question if its such a horrible myth??
Just wanted to tailor my debunking to your reasoning. As expected you went with the "more volume to fill" myth, and I've thankfully already got the answer for that one.

Originally Posted by Johnny
Just "Debunk" the bitch then.

You got it.

Most of the time I just link to a post I made a while back but I'll boil it down for you here. For a second lets forget about flow through the intercooler and imagine all we want to do is get the air compressed, since that's what you seem so hung up on. No matter that flowing the air through the intercooler will make more power than if it would compress in the intercooler. No, let's forget that for a second and just assume we want to pressurize the bitch.

What's the difference in volume between a smallish intercooler and a large intercooler? 2 liters at most? Okay good. How much does the engine displace? 2 liters? Excellent. How long does it take to pressurize the engine? Oh, two revolutions you say? Alright then... How long is one revolution at idle...

800 revolutions.....1 minute......= 13.3 revolutions
....1 minute............60 seconds........1 second

13.3 revolutions per second works out to 0.075 seconds per revolution, it takes two revolutions to fill the engine so it will take 0.075*2 or 0.15 seconds longer to fill another 2 liter cavity (not taking into account how much easier it is to fill or pressurize the intercooler compared to the engine chocked by tiny valves).

How long is one revolution at some normal operating rpm like 4,000?


4,000 revolutions.....1 minute......= 66.6 revolutions
....1 minute............60 seconds........1 second

66.6 revolutions per second works out to 0.015 seconds per revolution, so it will take 0.015*2 or 0.03 seconds longer to pressurize an additional 2 liter cavity at 4,000 rpm. The question is, would you find this significant enough to continue to recommend an intercooler smaller than another one based on the so-called delay in boost onset?

If you'd like something a little more fleshed out, read this:
Charge pipe sizing & differences: - e30tech.com Forums
Pay attention to post # 18 if you'd like a more general formula. That's a thread about charge pipe size and mythical additional "turbo lag".

Basically with 20-50 pounds of air per minute flowing through the charge pipes a couple of liters here and there are completely insignificant.

Originally Posted by Johnny
and...slower boost onset....turbo lag....same **** cause its gonna feel just like turbo lag till it builds pressure.
Oh really? Tell me what turbo lag feels like. I dare you.
+ Reply To Thread
  • [Type to search users.]
  • Quick Reply
    Thread Information
    There are currently ? users browsing this thread. (? members & ? guests)
    StubUserName

    Back to top