had the same thing happen with the baffle SE-Rawkus, the gear oil makes it stick to the bell housing side when you split the case. the baffle clips in on the gear case side just as you thought, actually thats the only way you'll be able to get the halfs back together with the baffle aligned properly. Also when putting the halfs back together make sure your shims are still where they were originally, your dowel pins are in the right spot, and the large C clip is aligned so you can spread it open as you slide the case back down..you'll have to spread the clip to get it start over the bearing. then once its all bolted back together you'll have to pull shaft into place till the clip locks into bearing. i used a coat hanger to pull it up