Welcome to the SR20 Community Forum - The Dash.
Register
SR20 forum logo

Thread: Quick! Best spark plug for a DE!

+ Reply To Thread
Posts: 31-40 of 55
2008-08-04 04:05:23
#31
Originally Posted by Vadim


So thats why I would trust what the manual would have to say, because Nissan would actually time the time to tune the plugs to the best performance/MPG for that specific motor.

.



The problem with that is Nissan never ran a Non Platinum Plug in the SR20 ... so ... I would bet they never spent any time with a non Platinum plug to tune them ...again ... they just asked NGK which plug was the Non Platinum equivalent of the OE Platinum plug ... and again at that time NGK had the wrong listing ... Again ... this is strait from an NGK Rep !!!
2008-08-04 11:13:12
#32
Originally Posted by Tearoffguy
ok now I'm confused,, the NGK BKR6E are the wrong plug?,,, or what do you mean by the extended tip plugs??


NO NO NO, not what I said or meant.

Here is what I meant: The guy who sold you the plugs knew that our Pistons don't have the extra space for extended electrode plugs, and probably things that regular BKR6E's are extended electrode plugs.

Originally Posted by Robchaos
The BKR6E is the right plug. I don't understand why there is so much confusion about this. Every dealership I have checked with has confirmed that BKR6E is the correct plug. If I went to my local Nissan dealership and bought 4 standard plugs for the SR20DE, which happen to be BKR6E, then I installed them and the pistons smashed into them, don't you think Nissan would have some major liability in that situation?


Your parts guy is 100% wrong.



No....Nissan never updates the catalog, which is why if you call and ask for Rocker arms or HLAs for a 1993 Sentra SE-R, you will get the UPDATED part number from the newer style SR20DEs. Why would Nissan have to update a plug part number that has not changed? I am sorry but if it comes down to listening to you, NGK, or Nissan on which plug should be run in their car. I will go with Nissan hands down, and I would recommend that anyone else out there who has has any doubt about it, should do the same.


I agree

About the bolded area, technically, if we listen o the manual, and follow it, and something screws up, can't we hold Nissan liable and force them to say give us a new engine if it comes down to that?

Originally Posted by SHAWNATGERBROCK
The problem with that is Nissan never ran a Non Platinum Plug in the SR20 ... so ... I would bet they never spent any time with a non Platinum plug to tune them ...again ... they just asked NGK which plug was the Non Platinum equivalent of the OE Platinum plug ... and again at that time NGK had the wrong listing ... Again ... this is strait from an NGK Rep !!!


Shawn, I will have to apologies to you, I miss read one of your first posts, about Nissan never using the non-platinum plugs. Do to your wording I thought you meant to say that Nissan never used/released a Platinum plug.

This does make it interesting. If Nissan didn't really test the regular plugs and just put them in the manual as a cheaper alternative.

Now for Platinums and Iridiums, did you mention that you do gap them or you don't? Also can you translate the 1.1mm to 1.4mm into standard numbers? .044 is which?

Thanks
2008-08-04 17:23:55
#33
Wow.......What a thread. NKG all day.
2008-08-04 21:38:37
#34
Originally Posted by Robchaos
The BKR6E is the right plug. I don't understand why there is so much confusion about this. Every dealership I have checked with has confirmed that BKR6E is the correct plug. If I went to my local Nissan dealership and bought 4 standard plugs for the SR20DE, which happen to be BKR6E, then I installed them and the pistons smashed into them, don't you think Nissan would have some major liability in that situation?


Your parts guy is 100% wrong.



No....Nissan never updates the catalog, which is why if you call and ask for Rocker arms or HLAs for a 1993 Sentra SE-R, you will get the UPDATED part number from the newer style SR20DEs. Why would Nissan have to update a plug part number that has not changed? I am sorry but if it comes down to listening to you, NGK, or Nissan on which plug should be run in their car. I will go with Nissan hands down, and I would recommend that anyone else out there who has has any doubt about it, should do the same.




thanks Rob,,,


Originally Posted by Vadim
NO NO NO, not what I said or meant.

Here is what I meant: The guy who sold you the plugs knew that our Pistons don't have the extra space for extended electrode plugs, and probably things that regular BKR6E's are extended electrode plugs.



I agree

About the bolded area, technically, if we listen o the manual, and follow it, and something screws up, can't we hold Nissan liable and force them to say give us a new engine if it comes down to that?



Shawn, I will have to apologies to you, I miss read one of your first posts, about Nissan never using the non-platinum plugs. Do to your wording I thought you meant to say that Nissan never used/released a Platinum plug.

This does make it interesting. If Nissan didn't really test the regular plugs and just put them in the manual as a cheaper alternative.

Now for Platinums and Iridiums, did you mention that you do gap them or you don't? Also can you translate the 1.1mm to 1.4mm into standard numbers? .044 is which?

Thanks



and thanks Vadim,,, I just miss understood what you said....

either we all are learning something here or just having fun with this.... I think I'm learning ,,,, sooooo THANKS to all of you even if a few of you disagree about this topic......
2008-08-04 21:48:33
#35
from my understanding you never gap platinum plugs because you may damage them
2008-08-04 22:34:37
#36
Originally Posted by Tearoffguy
thanks Rob,,,





and thanks Vadim,,, I just miss understood what you said....

either we all are learning something here or just having fun with this.... I think I'm learning ,,,, sooooo THANKS to all of you even if a few of you disagree about this topic......


That is very correct, it's hard to get information from people until you try to prove them wrong

Originally Posted by matt_pound
from my understanding you never gap platinum plugs because you may damage them


That is true, but you could always user pliers
2008-08-05 01:51:12
#37
I don't want to come off as an ass to you SHAWN, I am just trying to make my point. For whatever reason, Nissan felt that if you were using standard copper plugs in your SR20DE as opposed to platinum plugs, you should use a smaller gap. This would more then likely be due to the different wear characteristics and spark characteristics between the copper and platinum plugs.


The reason that all parts stores list the BKR6E-11s for the standard plug is because that is what cross references from the SR20DEs suggested platinum plug, the PFR6B-11.
It is obvious that nissan did not intend for the -11 to go into the SR20DE.

Nissan Had the BKR6E listed as the standard plug for the B13, B14, P10, and P11 SR20 powered cars. I do not think that Nissan would have made an uncorrected mistake that has spanned over 8 years.
I think that NGK is wrong. They are basing their statement that "Nissan has made a mistake" solely on the fact that the -11 is what cross references to the PFR6B-11. This is contrary to the fact that it says specifically in the FSM to gap a standard plug to 0.8-0.9 mm for the SR20.

I would think that the Nissan Engineers were the ones who decided what spark plug was suitable for each motor, not NGK engineers. NGK merely makes plugs of varying specifications.
Nissan did not go to NGK and say "we need a plug made of this material with this gap." The BKR6E was used in pre-1990s cars, so it was not specifically made for the SR20DE. Therefore this says to me that the BKR6E was chosen for a reason.



This is my take on it all, and of course the only way we could ever know for sure is talk to one of the engineers who designed the SR20 back in the day.
2008-08-05 02:04:42
#38
Reading some SE-R.net I found some similar to your information Shawn.

Link

The SR20 has a powerful stock ignition that can fire through turbo boost and NOS. Gap the plugs at 0.045". If you experience misfire under squeeze or high boost (and the rest of the ignition system is in good condition, like the cap, rotor and wires) you can close the gap down to as small as 0.020" to prevent it. Go down in 0.005" increments until the misfire stops. Higher cylinder pressures cause by big NOS or high boost requires smaller gaps with the stock ignition. The smaller gap loses a little power but this trick can tide you over until you can get that snazzy turkey roaster ignition.


I highlighted some ares. So the best to use is .045, but Nissan made the gaps smaller to prevent misfires etc.

I think I'll be ordering another set of BKR6E's and testing them with the .045 gap
2008-08-05 02:17:59
#39
Just saving you some time here, If gap the BKR6E at .045,it is the exact same thing as ordering the BKR6E-11. All the -11 designates is a larger gap.
2008-08-05 02:26:33
#40
Originally Posted by Robchaos
Just saving you some time here, If gap the BKR6E at .045,it is the exact same thing as ordering the BKR6E-11. All the -11 designates is a larger gap.


Good tip thanks Rob

More at SE-R.net!

http://www.se-r.net/engine/platinum_copper_ngk.html

Read through the article to why the Platinums have a higher gap and look at the bottom bolded sentence.

Platinum should be gapped at 0.039in to 0.044in and Copper at 0.031in and 0.035in.
+ Reply To Thread
  • [Type to search users.]
  • Quick Reply
    Thread Information
    There are currently ? users browsing this thread. (? members & ? guests)
    StubUserName

    Back to top