Originally Posted by
Ben I would much rather have a VQ'd B13/B14 than an Alitma. Altima is a DD car and maybe an occasional autocross or track car. A B13/B14 can be a drag car, racecar or a track car as well as a DD. The VQ auto transmissions suck.
Sure you can probably make a VE faster with the same money than the initial VQ swap, but when you start modding both of the engines to pull serious power out of them, the VQ will win and be cheaper. But it really comes down to owners choice what they like. If this kit comes out, I will surely buy another SE-R and eventully do this swap.
You are correct on a couple things, some others I don't think you are but it's a matter of opinion. I did in fact purchase my Altima for a daily driver, mainly because it has an incredible amount of cargo space for a mid size sedan (the trunk is huge!) and class leading power during the years it was new. Bigger than the Honda Accord V6 and Toyota Camry of the same year. Kind of a FWD, detuned version of the 350Z. I threw a cheap intake on mine for the sound. And you are correct, the Altima is not an auto-cross car, it's a boat, easy to lose control because of all the weight on the front of the car (3,400lbs I believe total) even with suspension upgrades. I'm an active member of the SCCA and I wouldn't even consider taking the Altima to an event.
The B13 is good for auto-crossing because they are relatively balanced, at least for a FWD car, and the suspension platform is great (much better than beam'd B14). They are no Miata's, but a B13 with the right suspension set up can hang with them pretty well. An experienced driver helps too.
I think all of this a cool idea, but if you throw a 3.5 V6 in a chassis that came with a 2.0 liter 4 cylinder, you're going to throw the balance off, unless you are mainly interested in straight line acceleration. Even then, I'd put money down that a bolt-on, properly tuned N/A SR20VE in a B13 would edge out a B13 with a VQ35DE swap with bolt ons in the 1/4 mile. The VQ is not exactly an easy motor to work on when it come to things like cams and springs, it would be a good idea to upgrade before installing the motor. I don't know about boost though.
Also, before messing with the VQ be aware of the NSB regarding the timing chain guides failing which damages the timing chain and will slowly ruin the motor. If you are one of the unlucky ones to get a VQ with that timing chain problem and can't do it yourself, an average shop will charge $1400+ to do the job, primarily for the labor. The replacement parts aren't all that much, it's just that getting inside that motor isn't easy. Just FYI.
One more thing, I disagree with you when you said that VQ's with the auto trans "suck." I actually really like mine. The tiptronic is good enough for me, and it's idiot proof, though it still keeps that manual feeling if you do it right. It will upshift if you rev too high, or downshift if you slow down too much, but other than that, when you're keeping an eye on it, it's does what it's meant to do. Car and Driver ran a 14.8 with the auto trans in a stock Altima SE-R. Not too bad.
If you have the money for all of this, by all means go for it!! Not here to rain on anyones parade. But $6,000+ for a VQ swap? You can get a 2004 Altima with that engine already for that price, and if you know what your doing, do the swap yourself then part out the Altima or sell the shell.... or just get a VE for $800ish from Andreas, add the proven bolt-ons like N1 cams, springs, good header, 3" exhaust, MSD box and a good tune.
P.S. - had the woman take a video with me the other day of the Altima from a dead stop with the intake. I do like the sound. It was just in Drive, no shifting here although I went to tiptronic for the two semi-sharp curves towards the end of the vid. At launch tires mostly spin thru first gear, I let off the throttle somewhere before redline in 3rd. Here's the vid:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=46jt0Nk6pxs