Welcome to the SR20 Community Forum - The Dash.
Register
SR20 forum logo

Thread: Should I usw this cams in my sr20de ?

+ Reply To Thread
Posts: 31-39 of 39
2011-03-04 07:16:38
#31
Originally Posted by yoshoto
Yes the material is porous andreas but it not pot metal, that is something totally different. Its chilled cast iron. I believe JWT used nissan blanks and in that case it would be chilled cast iron. Other than that it would be billet steel and its definitely not billet steel based on the pics and based on my own set of JWT S3R's.

ali86 have any of these shops actually seen the cam or the damage? it seems to me they think the cam is snapped in half or something like that.

repair to that material is possible if welded with the correct nickel rod, if you use anything else it can be welded but not machined. With the correct treatment of preheating and welding technique and cooldown there will be no warpage to the cam or stress points.

looks like the cam was dropped on the dowell pin end and this caused the pin to push out the bit at the back, pressure(trapped) or side force may have caused the crack along the side but all in all, if you put a new dowell hole at 180 to the original and do nothing else I cannot see that cam failing.

Wasn't it Charles Dundon that was having VE cams welded and reground? Have any of those cams warped or failed? It is the same material.


are you educated in the mechanics of materials? there is no way to every make this cam structurally sound again
2011-03-04 13:37:28
#32
Originally Posted by Will
are you educated in the mechanics of materials? there is no way to every make this cam structurally sound again


You know what would be good? If a mechanical engineer would chime in... even better would be one with failure analysis experience
2011-03-04 13:43:04
#33
How about common sense kicking in? It's damaged.It will damage other stuff it comes in contact with.It's a cancer.If you have to have race-y cams,just buy some new ones,and quit wasting your time and effort on fixing broken stuff.It's just not worth it.Move on.
2011-03-04 14:19:47
#34
Originally Posted by Bucky13
How about common sense kicking in? It's damaged.


Hi! Welcome to the forum. I think you missed the memo when signing up. All common sense is to be checked at the door before entering. Please return to the entrance and do so right away. This ensures that you fit in.
2011-03-04 17:23:11
#35
I know.What was I thinking.This is the internet,after all.
2011-03-04 23:22:57
#36
You know what would be good? If a mechanical engineer would chime in... even better would be one with failure analysis experience


This would be cool ^^

How about common sense kicking in? It's damaged.It will damage other stuff it comes in contact with.It's a cancer.If you have to have race-y cams,just buy some new ones,and quit wasting your time and effort on fixing broken stuff.It's just not worth it.Move on.


sry that's the most stupid I've ever heared. So how do you think most of the people make their expericen? By braking and repair, if you continue this way it will be quite impossible to learn something. But its your opinion.
2011-03-05 02:56:30
#37
Originally Posted by ali86
sry that's the most stupid I've ever heared. So how do you think most of the people make their expericen? By braking and repair, if you continue this way it will be quite impossible to learn something. But its your opinion.

When the "repair" might break again, this time inside the engine, I don't want that experience nor to learn that lesson.

I read everything I needed to know in post #23.
2011-03-05 03:07:44
#38
Originally Posted by Shawn
I read everything I needed to know in post #23.


Amen
2011-03-05 03:19:54
#39
hey, he wants to learn a lesson.. let him.
+ Reply To Thread
  • [Type to search users.]
  • Quick Reply
    Thread Information
    There are currently ? users browsing this thread. (? members & ? guests)
    StubUserName

    Back to top