
Originally Posted by
lynchfourtwenty
I'm curious, at what point is a catch can necessary? School me I'm a newb on this subject..
Seems to me that it's more of a tired worn out engine issue or a boosting crank case issue?
Depends who you ask and what you use it for. 1000ft race cars can fill a "catch can" in a single pass down the strip. So it's not just our tired old DE's.
Many people with newer DI turbocharged engines use a combination of "catch cans" and clean side separators to capture as much oil/gas vapor/condensation from caking up the back side of the intake valves subsequently covering the charge pipes and intake manifold in oil. This is a really big problem with the BMW crowd. Some manufactures are jumping on a DI + port hybrid fuel injection systems to get the best of both worlds and as an added benefit the fuel cleans the backside of the intake valves. Ex. FRS/BRZ - and now the new raptor ecoboost engines.
I have a 13' F150 ecoboost and everyone on the ecoboost forums swear by them as if it is black vodoo Magic. I personally rather install meth injection to clean the valves and keep my IAT's in check.
Then you have the guys like the local guy here with his DSM who seems to think that the catch can frees up a couple of ponies.
I'm sure the blow by in my case is from the worn out DE, it's more of a band aid than a fix. But if done right it can actually be benificial to even a freshly rebuilt engine.